Two Major League Soccer fixtures on Sunday offer sharp parlay angles. Here are the best combinations using live market odds.
Major League Soccer Parlay Picks - Sunday May 3, 2025
Two Major League Soccer fixtures light up Sunday's slate, and the markets are throwing up some genuinely interesting angles. We have New York City FC hosting D.C. United at 20:00 UTC, followed by Austin FC taking on St. Louis City SC at 22:30 UTC. Let's break down the value, build the best parlays, and flag where the books might have left some money on the table.
Match Analysis
New York City FC vs D.C. United (20:00 UTC)
New York City FC come in as heavy home favorites at -141 (theScore Bet), with D.C. United priced as big underdogs at +430 (Bally Bet). That -141 on NYCFC reflects a clear market lean toward the home side, and at Yankee Stadium - where NYCFC enjoy a partisan atmosphere and a compact pitch that suits their possession-based style - that pricing makes sense.
What's interesting here is the totals market. The line sits at 2.5 goals, with the Under at +104 (Bally Bet) - that's a positive-money Under, which immediately raises an eyebrow. Getting over-even odds on a sub-2.5 goal total in a game featuring a disciplined visiting side is genuine value. The BTTS No is also sitting at +100 (DraftKings), meaning the market isn't convinced both teams find the net. That aligns with a cautious D.C. United road approach.
Best Value Flag: Under 2.5 at +104 (Bally Bet) is a standout number. Implied probability here is under 50% for fewer than three goals - that seems low when you factor in a visiting side likely to park the bus.
Austin FC vs St. Louis City SC (22:30 UTC)
This one is far more open. Austin FC are modest home favorites at +160 (Caesars) - yes, the home side is priced as an underdog in American odds terms, which tells you the market views this as a genuinely competitive fixture. St. Louis City SC come in at +180 (Bally Bet), making this almost a coin-flip with a slight lean toward the visitors being capable of a result.
The BTTS Yes is priced at -159 (FanDuel) - that's a heavy favourite for both teams to score, suggesting oddsmakers expect an open, attacking game. The Over 2.5 sits at -130 (Bally Bet), which is a fairly standard price for a game with this much attacking expectation baked in.
Best Value Flag: St. Louis City SC at +180 (Bally Bet) looks generous if you believe this is a near-50-50 contest. Implied probability of roughly 36% for a road win when the actual probability might be closer to 45% is a meaningful edge.
Recommended Parlay Combinations
Parlay 1 - The Low-Scoring Double (2 legs)
- NYCFC to Win - -141 (theScore Bet)
- NYCFC vs DC United - Under 2.5 Goals - +104 (Bally Bet)
Combining the NYCFC win with the Under 2.5 in the same game is a coherent thesis - a tight, controlled home win where NYCFC grind out a 1-0 or 2-0 result. The Under at positive money supercharges the value here. Combined odds: approximately +120 to +130 depending on the book used. A solid two-legger with a strong logical narrative.
Parlay 2 - The Value Underdog Double (2 legs)
- St. Louis City SC to Win (ML) - +180 (Bally Bet)
- NYCFC vs DC United - Under 2.5 Goals - +104 (Bally Bet)
This combination pairs the best standalone value bet on the board - St. Louis at +180 - with the positive-money Under in New York. Two independently strong value positions combine here for attractive combined odds. Combined odds: approximately +470 to +490. Higher risk, but both legs carry genuine edge versus implied probability.
Parlay 3 - The Three-Leg Accumulator (3 legs)
- NYCFC to Win - -141 (theScore Bet)
- NYCFC vs DC United - BTTS No - +100 (DraftKings)
- Austin FC vs St. Louis City SC - Over 2.5 Goals - -130 (Bally Bet)
This three-legger tells two contrasting stories - a tight, low-scoring game in New York where NYCFC keep a clean sheet or limit DC to a blank, and a free-flowing, goal-heavy affair down in Austin. The narrative contrast actually makes sense given how differently these two games are priced. BTTS No at even money in New York is a great line to have in an accumulator. Combined odds: approximately +270 to +290. This is the recommended sweet spot for parlay bettors - enough legs to boost the payout without going overboard on risk.
Quick-Fire Odds Summary
- NYCFC Win: -141 (theScore Bet)
- D.C. United Win: +430 (Bally Bet) - massive price, minimal recommendation
- Draw NYCFC/DC: +300 (Bally Bet)
- Under 2.5 NYCFC/DC: +104 (Bally Bet) - VALUE
- BTTS No NYCFC/DC: +100 (DraftKings) - VALUE
- St. Louis City SC Win: +180 (Bally Bet) - VALUE
- Austin FC Win: +160 (Caesars)
- Over 2.5 Austin/STL: -130 (Bally Bet)
- BTTS Yes Austin/STL: -159 (FanDuel)
Final Verdict
Sunday's Major League Soccer double-header gives sharp bettors two very different games to work with. The standout value on the board is the Under 2.5 at +104 in New York - positive-money Unders on 2.5 goal lines deserve attention every time. St. Louis City SC at +180 is the other number that looks a touch generous given how open the Austin matchup appears. Our top recommendation is Parlay 3 at roughly +280, blending a tight New York result with a high-scoring Austin showdown for a well-rounded three-leg ticket.
Please gamble responsibly - only bet what you can afford to lose, and use deposit limits or self-exclusion tools if betting stops being fun.
