Huge Wednesday Major League Baseball slate with 16 games on the card. Here are our best parlay combinations with value odds highlighted.
Wednesday's Best Major League Baseball Parlay Picks - September 23, 2026
A monster 16-game Wednesday Major League Baseball slate gives us plenty of angles to work with as the 2026 regular season heads toward its conclusion. Playoff races, pride on the line, and some genuinely juicy odds on offer - let's cut through the noise and find the best parlay value available today.
Analysing the Best Legs for Wednesday's Parlays
Minnesota Twins -1.5 (+120) - theScore Bet
The Minnesota Twins travel to Oracle Park to face a San Francisco Giants side that has been inconsistent at home down the stretch. Getting run-line value at +120 on the Twins -1.5 is genuinely generous - you're essentially backing the Twins to win by two or more runs and getting paid plus money to do it. The total sitting at 7.5 suggests pitching is expected to be competitive, but the Twins have shown enough offensive firepower to cover against a Giants team with nothing tangible left to play for. This is the standout value leg of the day.
New York Yankees -1.5 (+156) - Caesars
The New York Yankees hosting the Tampa Bay Rays at Yankee Stadium with playoff seeding implications on the line is a dream setup for the home side. The Yankees are the kind of team that locks in for these late-season home games, and +156 on the run line is a fantastic price for a team favored at -149 on the moneyline. The implied probability on that spread price is only around 39% - the market is giving you real value here. Total sits at a low 7, signalling a pitching duel, but the Yankees should have enough to pull away late.
Arizona Diamondbacks -1.5 (-102) - FanDuel
Head to Coors Field and the Arizona Diamondbacks are genuine -1.5 run line favourites at near-even money (-102 on FanDuel). Colorado is notoriously generous at home in terms of run-scoring, yet the total of 11 reflects the altitude effect. The Diamondbacks have the pitching depth and lineup quality to dominate a Rockies team that has nothing to play for. Near-even money on a -1.5 line for a team of Arizona's caliber late in the season is a value you cannot ignore.
Los Angeles Dodgers -1.5 (+100) - theScore Bet
The Los Angeles Dodgers at +100 on the run line against the San Diego Padres is perhaps the most surprising price on the entire board today. The Dodgers are -208 on the moneyline - a colossal favourite - yet you can back them to win by two or more runs at even money. Structurally, this is one of the best spreads-vs-moneyline divergences of the season. The Padres have rotation and bullpen concerns at this stage of the year, and Dodger Stadium at the end of the regular season is a fortress. Flag this as a premium value leg.
Philadelphia Phillies +1.5 (-145) - BetMGM
A safer anchor leg - the Philadelphia Phillies at home, taking the +1.5 run line against the Milwaukee Brewers. Citizens Bank Park in September with the Phillies fighting for positioning is a tough environment for any visitor. At -145 the price is not exceptional in isolation, but it makes a reliable anchor in a multi-leg parlay where you need to lock in a near-certain outcome.
St. Louis Cardinals ML (+102) - Courtside
The Cardinals getting plus money on the moneyline against the Pittsburgh Pirates is a genuine value spot. Pittsburgh is installed as a slight home favourite at -114, but St. Louis at +102 is a team capable of winning this game outright more than half the time. The Cardinals have rotation depth the Pirates simply cannot match. Flag this as an underdog value leg - plus money for a team with real win equity is exactly what we look for.
Wednesday September 23 Parlay #1 - The Run-Line Value Hammer (3-Leg)
- Minnesota Twins -1.5 (+120) - theScore Bet
- New York Yankees -1.5 (+156) - Caesars
- Los Angeles Dodgers -1.5 (+100) - theScore Bet
Three run-line favourites, all offering plus money or near even money. The Dodgers leg alone at +100 is absurd value given that -208 moneyline. Combined odds on this three-legger land around +584 - a $100 bet returns $684. This is the headline play of the day.
Wednesday September 23 Parlay #2 - The Value Underdog Teaser (3-Leg)
- St. Louis Cardinals ML (+102) - Courtside
- Arizona Diamondbacks -1.5 (-102) - FanDuel
- Philadelphia Phillies +1.5 (-145) - BetMGM
A smarter, more balanced parlay mixing a genuine underdog value pick with two run-line plays at reasonable prices. The Cardinals plus money is the spice, Arizona at near-even run line is the value, and Philly +1.5 is the anchor. Combined odds come in around +278, giving solid returns with a more balanced risk profile.
Wednesday September 23 Parlay #3 - The Totals Angle (2-Leg)
- Toronto Blue Jays @ Baltimore Orioles (Game 1) - Over 7.5 (+100) - BetMGM
- Houston Astros @ Seattle Mariners - Under 7.5 (+110) - theScore Bet
A two-leg totals parlay targeting the best-priced over and under on the board. The Blue Jays-Orioles game one total at +100 for the over is excellent value - both offences have scoring capability and early-afternoon pitching match-ups tend to go over more frequently. The Astros-Mariners under at +110 on theScore Bet is a standout price - plus money for an under in a 7.5-total game in Seattle, one of the most pitcher-friendly parks in baseball. Combined odds on this two-legger reach approximately +310.
Value Flags Summary
- Los Angeles Dodgers -1.5 (+100) - theScore Bet - Dodgers are -208 ML favourites yet +100 on the run line. Exceptional divergence.
- New York Yankees -1.5 (+156) - Caesars - Only ~39% implied probability for a team favored at -149 ML. Strong overlay.
- Houston Astros @ Seattle Mariners Under 7.5 (+110) - theScore Bet - Plus money on an under in a pitcher-friendly park is always worth noting.
- St. Louis Cardinals ML (+102) - Courtside - Plus money on a team with genuine win equity against Pittsburgh. Back it.
Gambling should be fun - always bet within your means and use responsible gambling tools if you need support.
