Five FA Cup fixtures hit the pitch Tuesday evening. Here are the best parlay combinations from tonight's slate, with value legs flagged across the board.
FA Cup Tuesday Parlay Picks - October 6, 2026
Five FA Cup fixtures are on the card Tuesday evening, and while these are lower-league ties, the odds markets are loaded with value. Non-league and National League football can be unpredictable, but sharp parlay builders know that totals and underdog 1X2 legs in these rounds often carry generous prices. Let's break down tonight's slate and identify the best combinations.
Match-by-Match Breakdown
Spalding United FC vs Bury Town FC (19:45 UTC)
Spalding are installed as clear favourites at -135 (BetMGM), and the market leans heavily toward a low-scoring affair. The Under 2.5 is priced at -108 (BetMGM) - that's a relatively short price but reflects genuine expectation of a tight, scrappy FA Cup tie. When home favourites at this level grind out wins, they tend to do it 1-0 or 2-0. The Under 2.5 here is our anchor leg.
Atherton Collieries AFC vs Trafford FC (19:45 UTC)
This is the standout value fixture on the slate. Atherton are priced as slight home underdogs at +110 (BetMGM), which is unusual for a home side in early-round FA Cup football. The Over 2.5 is a heavy favourite at -156 (betPARX), suggesting bookmakers expect goals - but we get paid at +120 (BetMGM) to take the Under 2.5 if you want the contrarian lean. However, the real flag here is Atherton +110 as a home pick - that price represents genuine value when you consider the built-in advantage of playing on home turf.
Scarborough Athletic FC vs Macclesfield Town (19:45 UTC)
The most balanced fixture on the card. Scarborough are priced at +185 (BetMGM) at home, while Macclesfield come in as road favourites at +135 (BetMGM). The draw sits at +260 (BetMGM). Interestingly, the Over 2.5 is priced at -105 (BetMGM) - nearly a coin flip - which is rare value on an over/under market. When both sides are evenly matched and neither is a massive favourite, games tend to be more open. This Over 2.5 at -105 is flagged as a strong value leg.
Wingate and Finchley FC vs Bedford Town FC (19:45 UTC)
Bedford Town arrive as slight road favourites at +104 (betPARX), making this essentially a pick'em game with a fractional edge to the visitors. The Over 2.5 is priced at -132 (betPARX), which is a bit steep. We'll leave this one alone for parlay purposes given the thin edges on offer.
Halesowen Town FC vs Stafford Rangers FC (19:45 UTC)
The most lopsided line of the night. Halesowen are heavy home favourites at -135 (BetMGM), while Stafford Rangers are priced at a massive +310 (BetMGM). That Stafford underdog price is eye-catching, but the market clearly has strong conviction in Halesowen. The Under 2.5 at +120 (BetMGM) is our value flag here - when big home favourites are expected to win comfortably, they often manage games tightly rather than racking up goals.
Recommended FA Cup Parlay Combinations
Parlay 1 - The Value Under Treble (Best Combined Pick)
- Spalding United FC - Under 2.5 Goals at -108 (BetMGM)
- Halesowen Town FC - Under 2.5 Goals at +120 (BetMGM)
- Scarborough Athletic FC vs Macclesfield Town - Over 2.5 Goals at -105 (BetMGM)
Two tight home-favourite matches paired with the wide-open Scarborough vs Macclesfield clash. The Over 2.5 at -105 on that game is the value engine of this parlay. Combined parlay odds land around +237.
Parlay 2 - The Home Underdogs Double
- Atherton Collieries AFC - Home Win at +110 (BetMGM)
- Scarborough Athletic FC - Over 2.5 Goals at -105 (BetMGM)
Atherton at +110 at home is the standout value flag of the evening. Home advantage in lower-league football is a real factor, and the market appears to be slightly underrating it here. Pair it with the near-even Over 2.5 in the Scarborough match for a punchy two-legger. Combined parlay odds land around +231.
Parlay 3 - The Upsets and Goals Treble
- Atherton Collieries AFC - Home Win at +110 (BetMGM)
- Halesowen Town FC - Under 2.5 Goals at +120 (BetMGM)
- Scarborough Athletic FC vs Macclesfield Town - Over 2.5 Goals at -105 (BetMGM)
A more aggressive three-legger mixing the Atherton home value play with two totals picks. The combined odds here are around +382 - a juicy return on three well-reasoned legs. Atherton at plus money at home is the standout value leg of the entire slate and anchors this combination nicely.
Tonight's Value Flag Summary
- Best value leg: Atherton Collieries AFC to win at home (+110, BetMGM) - home sides in the FA Cup rarely get plus-money treatment
- Best totals value: Scarborough vs Macclesfield Over 2.5 at -105 (BetMGM) - nearly even money on a goal-heavy open game
- Best long-shot eye-catcher: Stafford Rangers ML +310 (BetMGM) - tempting but risky; leave for small singles only
Good luck with tonight's FA Cup action. Remember to shop lines across books before placing - small differences in price add up across a parlay.
Please gamble responsibly - bet only what you can afford to lose, and visit BeGambleAware.org if you need support.
