Chalkboard, PrizePicks or Underdog won't take your lineup? Here's why some picks can't be combined and how to fix it.
You're building a pick'em lineup and the app stops you: "These picks can't be combined." Or the entry looks fine until you tap submit and get "One or more picks couldn't be added." Pick'em apps such as Chalkboard, PrizePicks and Underdog all limit which picks can sit in one entry. Here's why, what each rule looks like, and how to get your lineup through.
Why Pick'em Apps Block Some Combinations
The reason is correlation. When two picks tend to win together, multiplying their payouts as if they were independent would overpay. Chalkboard explains it plainly: when the correlation between two picks is too strong, "the combined multiplier exceeds what our system can fairly price." The classic example is a quarterback's passing yards with his own receiver's receiving yards in the same game. If one goes over, the other is more likely to.
The Two Chalkboard Messages
- "These picks can't be combined. Remove one to keep building your entry." This appears while you're building, when two picks break a built-in correlation rule. Remove one of the pair.
- "One or more picks couldn't be added." This appears after you tap submit, when the combination can't be priced at that moment or a market has been suspended. Review the picks, remove the conflicting one and submit again.
PrizePicks Lineup Rules
PrizePicks publishes its lineup rules. The ones that most often stop an entry:
- Picks must come from at least two different teams.
- The same player can't appear twice, unless Stacks are offered for that player.
- Lineups have 2 to 6 picks, and Colorado residents need at least 3.
- Some sports have their own limits. For example, you can't have a pitcher and an opposing batter in the same lineup.
- Culture Picks and Free Picks can't be combined with Player Picks.
Underdog and Other Apps
Underdog and other pick'em apps use similar limits on related picks, and the exact rules vary by sport and contest type, so check the rules page for the game you're playing. The fix is the same everywhere: find the two picks that depend on each other and replace one.
How to Fix a Blocked Lineup
- Look for teammates and opponents in the same game. QB and his receiver, pitcher and opposing hitters, a player and his own team's total are the usual suspects.
- Check the two-team rule. Add a pick from a different team if every pick is from one side.
- Remove duplicates of the same player.
- Resubmit after a market suspension. If the error came on submit, wait for the market to reopen or swap the pick.
What Happens If a Player Doesn't Play or Ties?
On PrizePicks, a player who doesn't play (DNP) is removed from the lineup and the lineup drops one payout tier, so a 3-pick Power Play becomes a 2-pick Power Play. A tied projection counts as neither correct nor incorrect and also lowers the payout. A reboot drops the lineup down one tier too.
Pick'em vs a Same Game Parlay
If you want correlated picks together, such as a QB and his receiver, a sportsbook Same Game Parlay is built for exactly that, where sports betting is legal. The book prices the correlation instead of blocking it, and the price differs a lot between books. Our betslip shows what the whole parlay pays at every sportsbook we track. If a regular sportsbook parlay is refusing your legs instead, see why DraftKings and Fanatics won't combine some picks.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does "these picks can't be combined" mean on Chalkboard?
Two of your picks are too closely linked for Chalkboard to price together. Remove one of them to keep building.
Why does PrizePicks say my lineup is invalid?
Most often all picks are from one team, a player is in twice, or the lineup mixes a pitcher with an opposing batter. PrizePicks needs picks from at least two different teams.
Can I pick a quarterback and his receiver together?
Many pick'em apps block or limit that pairing because the results are linked. A sportsbook Same Game Parlay usually allows it, priced for the correlation.
Pick'em contests are available only in some states, and age limits apply. Please play responsibly. If gambling is affecting your finances or wellbeing, call the National Problem Gambling Helpline at 1-800-522-4700 for free, confidential support.